HomeHubsAppleQualcomm Inc asks US trade regulators to reverse a judge ruling and ban on some iPhones import

Qualcomm Inc asks US trade regulators to reverse a judge ruling and ban on some iPhones import

Most Read

Qualcomm Inc is urging US trade regulators to reverse a judge’s ruling and ban the import of some Apple Inc iPhones in a long-running patent fight between the two companies.

Qualcomm is seeking the ban in hopes of dealing Apple a blow before the two begin a major trial in mid-April in San Diego over Qualcomm’s patent licensing practices.

- Advertisement -

Qualcomm has sought to apply pressure to Apple with smaller legal challenges ahead of that trial and has won partial iPhone sales bans in China and Germany against Apple, forcing the iPhone maker to ship only phones with Qualcomm chips to some markets.

Any possible ban on iPhone imports to the United States could be short-lived because Apple last week for the first time disclosed that it has found a software fix to avoid infringing on one of Qualcomm’s patents. Apple asked regulators to give it as much as six months to prove that the fix works.

Qualcomm brought a case against Apple at the U.S International Trade Commission in 2017 alleging that some iPhones violated Qualcomm patents to help smart phones run well without draining their batteries. Qualcomm asked for an import ban on some older iPhone models containing Intel Corp chips.

In September, Thomas Pender, an administrative law judge at the ITC, found that Apple violated one of the patents in the case but declined to issue a ban. Pender reasoned that imposing a ban on Intel-chipped iPhones would hand Qualcomm an effective monopoly on the U.S. market for modem chips, which connect smart phones to wireless data networks.

Pender’s ruling said that preserving competition in the modem chip market was in the public interest as speedier 5G networks come online in the next few years.

Cases where the ITC finds patent violations but does not ban the import of products are rare. In December, the full ITC said it would review Pender’s decision and decide whether to uphold or reverse it by late March.

In filings that became public late last week ahead of the full commission’s decision, Apple for the first time said that it had developed a software fix to avoid running afoul of Qualcomm’s patent. Apple said it did not discover the fix until after the trial and that it implemented the new software “last fall.”

But Apple said that it would need six months to verify that the fix will satisfy regulators and to sell its existing inventory. Apple asked the full commission to delay any possible import ban by that long if the commission reverses the judge’s decisions.

In a filing late on Friday, Qualcomm argued that Apple’s disclosure of a fix undermined the reasoning in Pender’s decision and that the Intel-chipped phones should be banned while Apple deploys its fix.

“Pender recommended against a remedy on the assumption that the (Qualcomm) patent would preclude Apple from using Intel as a supplier for many years and that no redesign was feasible,” Qualcomm wrote. “Apple now admits-more than seven months after the hearing-that the alleged harm is entirely avoidable.”

Subscribe To Morning Newsletters

Sign up to receive the latest news stories, exclusive interviews, and more in your inbox.

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

Editor's Pick

Krishna Mali
Krishna Mali
Founder, CEO & Group Editor of TechGraph.

Read More Stories

SKF Showcases Intelligent & Clean Solutions for the Textile Industry at International Textile Machinery Exhibition (ITME) 2022

SKF India, the country's leading technology and solutions provider of bearings and services will showcase innovative products and solutions...

OneRare and Cornitos: Bringing the Magic of Cornitos to the Foodverse

Cornitos is a leader in the Snack category and has always strived to give its fans and patrons the...

Chitkara University Signs MoU with NEC Corporation India to Transform Learning in the Field of AI/ML

Chitkara University announced its collaboration with NEC Corporation India, a wholly owned subsidiary of NEC Corporation, for a comprehensive...

Role of skills-based hiring in promoting inclusive economic growth in India

In recent years, India's employment landscape has experienced a profound shift, with an increasing emphasis on skills-based hiring. This...

Data Insights into Action: Techwave CEO Raj Gummadapu On Tech-Driven Approach to Business Empowerment

In an interview with TechGraph, Raj Gummadapu, Co-Founder & CEO of Techwave discussed the company's nuanced approach to Digital...

VTION Digital Appoints Srividya TN to Drive Growth & Strategic Business Development Partnerships

VTION Digital, a leading consumer behaviour measurement & analytics company, is proud to announce the appointment of Ms Srividya...