Human-in-the-Loop: Why AI in Education Still Needs the Professor

PUBLISHED:

See more TechGraph stories in your search results.
Google Add TechGraph on Google

Generative AI is rapidly entering classrooms, boardrooms, and training programs. Yet a critical question remains unresolved: does AI enhance learning, or quietly replace it?

In my recent research published in the International Journal of Management Education, I examine a faculty-led model of integrating generative AI into executive economics teaching. Conducted across eight Executive MBA cohorts, the study finds that structured use of AI, when guided by faculty, significantly improves student performance, particularly among lower-performing learners.

- Advertisement -

This is not a story about AI replacing educators. It is a story about what happens when AI is carefully designed into the learning process.

The Problem with “Plug-and-Play” AI in Education

Much of the current conversation around AI in education is driven by tools: AI tutors, automated grading, or content generation systems. These solutions promise efficiency but often miss the core purpose of education: developing judgment, not just answers.

In executive education, this challenge is even sharper. Participants are not passive learners; they are decision-makers. They bring experience, context, and real-world constraints. A generic AI tool, however powerful, cannot replicate that nuance.

The risk is subtle but important: when AI becomes an answer engine, learners may outsource thinking rather than deepen it.

A Different Approach: AI as a Thinking Partner

The model I tested takes a different route. Instead of treating AI as a shortcut, it positions AI as a Socratic partner, a tool that supports questioning, refinement, and reflection.

In practice, this involved three key design elements.

First, structured prompting: students interacted with AI through guided, scenario-based questions tied to real business dilemmas.

Second, iterative dialogue: AI was used not to generate final answers, but to test reasoning, challenge assumptions, and refine arguments.

Third, annotated transcripts: students submitted their AI interactions, explaining where they agreed, disagreed, or revised their thinking.

This last step is critical. It shifts AI use from passive consumption to active engagement. Students are not just using AI; they are learning how to think with it.

What the Data Shows

The results were clear.

Students in AI-supported cohorts scored, on average, 2.45 points higher (out of 40) than those in traditional cohorts. More importantly, the gains were not evenly distributed.

Lower-performing students benefited the most.

- Advertisement -

Analysis across different performance levels showed that AI support had the strongest impact at the lower end of the distribution, suggesting that structured AI use can act as an equaliser in learning outcomes.

This is a significant insight. Much of the fear around AI in education focuses on unfair advantage or misuse. But when designed properly, AI can reduce disparities rather than widen them.

Why Faculty Still Matter, More Than Ever

One of the most important findings from the study is that the impact did not come solely from AI. It came from how AI was integrated.

The same tool can produce very different outcomes depending on instructional design. Without structure, AI leads to surface-level summaries. Structure enables deeper reasoning. This places faculty at the centre of the process. Their role evolves, but it does not diminish. Instead, it expands.

Faculty become prompt designers, framing the right questions that guide learning. They act as cognitive coaches, helping students interpret and challenge AI outputs. And they serve as ethical anchors, ensuring transparency, authorship, and responsible use. In this sense, the “human-in-the-loop” is not a limitation; it is the source of value.

Implications Beyond the Classroom

While this study is grounded in executive economics education, the implications extend much further.

In corporate training, leadership development, and workplace decision-making, AI is increasingly used as a support tool. The same principle applies: AI creates value not when it replaces thinking, but when it structures better thinking.

For organisations, this suggests a shift away from simply adopting AI tools toward designing AI-enabled processes. The focus should be on how individuals interact with AI, not just whether they use it.

For educators and institutions, it highlights the need for intentional integration rather than reactive adoption driven by technological trends.

The Hidden Layer: Behavioural and Cognitive Impact

There is also a behavioural dimension that deserves attention.

Students initially expressed hesitation, uncertainty about ethics, over-reliance, or even the legitimacy of using AI in learning. However, when guided properly, this hesitation evolved into confidence and curiosity.

This aligns with behavioural economics. Tools alone do not change outcomes; structure, framing, and incentives do. In this context, AI acts as a nudge. It can either push learners toward deeper engagement or reinforce shortcuts, depending on how it is designed.

A More Realistic Future for AI in Education

The future of AI in education will sit between full automation and traditional teaching. The question is not whether AI should be used, but how.

This research points to a simple direction: keep AI in the loop but faculty in control; design for thinking, not just output; and focus on learning, not just engagement. In an algorithm-driven world, the ability to question, interpret, and apply knowledge becomes more valuable, not less.

But beyond performance lies responsibility.

A sustainability mindset in AI-enabled learning calls for three shifts. Cognitively, learners must question AI outputs rather than accept them at face value. Behaviourally, they must use AI to deepen reasoning, not replace it. Affectively, they must remain aware of how their decisions shape organisations, society, and long-term outcomes.

When these come together, AI moves from a productivity tool to a decision-making partner grounded in responsibility. The real opportunity is not just to teach students how to use AI, but to shape how they think, act, and decide with it.

That is where human judgment remains essential.

Stay ahead of the curve, every day.

A daily briefing covering news, interviews, and the trends driving the world forward. Curated for readers who want news, not noise.

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

- Advertisement -
Muniza Askari
Muniza Askari
Muniza Askari, Assistant Professor, Economics at SP Jain School of Global Management.

Top Gainers · Global

View all
NamePriceChange
TMCVTata Motors ₹445.65 +4.21%
QNBKQNB Group QAR 18.30 +4.10%
PCGPG&E Corporation $13.68 +3.25%
ADANIENTAdani Enterprises ₹2,745.10 +3.24%
MUMicron Technology $737.00 +2.58%

Latest Stories

The Integration Work Behind Selling Building Software

The demo usually goes well. A dashboard loads, a...

Why Technology Distributors Matter in India’s AI Journey

India's AI conversation usually centres on models, compute, and...

What to Do If You Suspect Workplace Discrimination Led to Your Dismissal

No one should ever feel uncomfortable in their workplace,...

How Multi-Extortion Is Changing the Economics of Ransomware Attacks

Over the years, ransomware attacks have changed from disrupting...

The Art of Ending a Gaming Session on Your Own Terms

If you enjoy online casino gaming, knowing when to...

Related Articles

The Integration Work Behind Selling Building Software

The demo usually goes well. A dashboard loads, a chart shows heating performance floor by floor, and the owner can picture the building being...

Why Technology Distributors Matter in India’s AI Journey

India's AI conversation usually centres on models, compute, and startups. These matter, but they are only one part of the story. The real outcome will be decided by adoption, and adoption happens in thousands of businesses far from the headlines. Between the technology and...

What to Do If You Suspect Workplace Discrimination Led to Your Dismissal

No one should ever feel uncomfortable in their workplace, feel that they aren’t valued,...

How Multi-Extortion Is Changing the Economics of Ransomware Attacks

Over the years, ransomware attacks have changed from disrupting the regular functioning of businesses...

Why Pop-Up Retail Demands Nimble Financial Tech

Running a pop-up shop is stressful enough without worrying about failed payments, long checkout...

Preparing Construction Sites for the Transition From Earthwork to Building Construction

A construction project often begins long before the first walls or roof components arrive....

ClearMountCap Explained: The Platform Behind “Read the Room Before You Trade”

“Read the Room Before You Trade” is a more useful trading message than it...

Redeeming a Tokenized Stock: Why the Route Back to the Underlying Share Matters

What is stock tokenization? It is a way to represent stock-related securities on a...

Are Dating Apps Making It Harder to Find Long Term Relationships?

Marriages that begin online end slightly less often than marriages that begin offline. A...

Redeeming a Tokenized Stock: Why the Route Back to the Underlying Share Matters

What is stock tokenization? It is a way to represent stock-related securities on a...

Are Dating Apps Making It Harder to Find Long Term Relationships?

Marriages that begin online end slightly less often than marriages that begin offline. A...

The Changing Landscape of Real Estate: Housing Trends, Growth, and Opportunities

The real estate market has been undergoing significant changes over the past few years,...

Shopping Online This Diwali? Five Cybersecurity Risks to Watch For

Diwali is one of the busiest shopping periods of the year in India. However,...

Can Interactive Displays Bridge the Gap in Hybrid Collaboration?

Picture the last hybrid meeting you attended. A few colleagues sat around a table,...

The Art of Ending a Gaming Session on Your Own Terms

If you enjoy online casino gaming, knowing when to call it a day helps keep the experience sustainable and compatible with your everyday responsibilities....

The Changing Landscape of Real Estate: Housing Trends, Growth, and Opportunities

The real estate market has been undergoing significant changes over the past few years,...

Shopping Online This Diwali? Five Cybersecurity Risks to Watch For

Diwali is one of the busiest shopping periods of the year in India. However,...

From Alerts to Answers: How AI Is Rewriting Fraud Detection in Financial Services

Every bank, credit union, and payments company runs on a quiet paradox. The systems...

From Alerts to Answers: How AI Is Rewriting Fraud Detection in Financial Services

Every bank, credit union, and payments company runs on a quiet paradox. The systems...

Cybersecurity Is Becoming Central to Trust in India’s Fintech Sector

India’s digital finance story is one of scale, convenience and growing adoption. People can...

How Agentic AI Is Changing the Future of Cybersecurity

For ten years, AI in security was a smart filter. It ranked alerts. It...

The Mobile Banking AI Permission Matrix: What an Assistant Can Access, Recommend, and Execute

A customer asks a mobile banking assistant to explain recent spending, suggest a savings...