Apple defends its iPhone app fees in Court

PUBLISHED:

See more TechGraph stories in your search results.
Google Add TechGraph on Google

Apple is at the Supreme Court to defend the way it sells apps for iPhones against claims by consumers that the company has unfairly monopolized the market.

The justices are hearing arguments Monday in Apple’s effort to end an antitrust lawsuit that could force the iPhone maker to cut the 30 percent commission it charges software developers whose apps are sold exclusively through Apple’s App Store. A judge could triple the compensation to consumers under antitrust law if Apple ultimately loses the lawsuit.

- Advertisement -

Apple says it doesn’t own the apps or sell them. That’s the responsibility of software developers.

But the lawsuit says the Cupertino, California-based company exerts a lot of control over the process, including a requirement that prices end in .99. And iPhone apps are only available through the App Store.

The issue for the Supreme Court is whether Apple can even be sued about the apps, given prior high court rulings in antitrust cases. In other cases, the justices have said there must be a direct relationship between the seller and a party complaining about unfair, anticompetitive pricing.

Consumers can choose from among more than 2 million apps, up from the 500 apps that were available when Apple created the App Store in 2008. “The phrase ‘there’s an app for that’ is now part of the popular lexicon,” Chief Justice John Roberts noted in a 2014 decision limiting warrantless searches of cellphones by police. Apple has trademarked the phrase.

But the company says the popularity of software for iPhones and its App Store shouldn’t obscure that consumers buys apps from developers, not Apple.

“Apple is a sales and distribution agent for developers,” Apple’s lawyers said in a Supreme Court filing. “Apple’s core argument has always been that any injury to consumers necessarily depends on developer pass-through decisions, since Apple does not set apps prices.”

Apple takes a 30 percent commission on the sale of apps, but it says any complaints about its pricing structure should come from developers, not consumers, since it’s the developers who pay the commission. The Trump administration is backing Apple at the high court.

A trial court initially dismissed the lawsuit, but the 9th US Circuit Court of Appeals revived it.

Lawyers for the consumers urged the high court to allow the lawsuit to proceed. Consumers “pay the monopoly prices for apps directly to Apple through its App Store,” the lawyers wrote in their Supreme Court brief. That direct relationship makes Apple the proper target of an antitrust lawsuit, they said.

A victory for Apple could severely restrict consumers’ ability to sue over antitrust violations even though Congress envisioned such lawsuits “would form a central component of enforcement of the antitrust laws,” warned 18 scholars of antitrust law in a Supreme Court filing.

A decision in Apple Inc. v Pepper, 17-204, is expected by late spring.

Stay ahead of the curve, every day.

A daily briefing covering news, interviews, and the trends driving the world forward. Curated for readers who want news, not noise.

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

- Advertisement -
Krishna Mali
Krishna Mali
Founder & Group Editor of TechGraph.

Top Gainers · Global

View all
NamePriceChange
ITCITC ₹295.10 +4.09%
PCGPG&E Corporation $13.72 +3.51%
TATACONSUMTata Consumer Products ₹1,117.50 +3.35%
NESTLEINDNestlé India ₹1,297.00 +2.98%
BHARTIARTLBharti Airtel ₹2,153.50 +2.85%

Latest Stories

Preparing Construction Sites for the Transition From Earthwork to Building Construction

A construction project often begins long before the first...

ClearMountCap Explained: The Platform Behind “Read the Room Before You Trade”

“Read the Room Before You Trade” is a more...

Redeeming a Tokenized Stock: Why the Route Back to the Underlying Share Matters

What is stock tokenization? It is a way to...

Are Dating Apps Making It Harder to Find Long Term Relationships?

Marriages that begin online end slightly less often than...

The Changing Landscape of Real Estate: Housing Trends, Growth, and Opportunities

The real estate market has been undergoing significant changes...

Related Articles

Preparing Construction Sites for the Transition From Earthwork to Building Construction

A construction project often begins long before the first walls or roof components arrive. Crews must prepare the property, establish suitable elevations, address drainage,...

ClearMountCap Explained: The Platform Behind “Read the Room Before You Trade”

“Read the Room Before You Trade” is a more useful trading message than it may first appear. Markets rarely move because of one isolated factor. A currency can react to interest-rate expectations, gold may move because of the same change in rates, an equity...

Redeeming a Tokenized Stock: Why the Route Back to the Underlying Share Matters

What is stock tokenization? It is a way to represent stock-related securities on a...

Are Dating Apps Making It Harder to Find Long Term Relationships?

Marriages that begin online end slightly less often than marriages that begin offline. A...

Shopping Online This Diwali? Five Cybersecurity Risks to Watch For

Diwali is one of the busiest shopping periods of the year in India. However,...

Can Interactive Displays Bridge the Gap in Hybrid Collaboration?

Picture the last hybrid meeting you attended. A few colleagues sat around a table,...

Cybersecurity Is Becoming Central to Trust in India’s Fintech Sector

India’s digital finance story is one of scale, convenience and growing adoption. People can...

How Agentic AI Is Changing the Future of Cybersecurity

For ten years, AI in security was a smart filter. It ranked alerts. It...

The Mobile Banking AI Permission Matrix: What an Assistant Can Access, Recommend, and Execute

A customer asks a mobile banking assistant to explain recent spending, suggest a savings...

How Agentic AI Is Changing the Future of Cybersecurity

For ten years, AI in security was a smart filter. It ranked alerts. It...

The Mobile Banking AI Permission Matrix: What an Assistant Can Access, Recommend, and Execute

A customer asks a mobile banking assistant to explain recent spending, suggest a savings...

Free Crypto Trading Signals: How to Judge a Prediction Before You Trust It

Learn how to assess free crypto trading signals, check the original claim, compare outcomes fairly, and spot gaps in a published record.

The Building Blocks of Academic Success: Learning, Play, and Physical Activity

Academic success is a multifaceted concept that goes far beyond the boundaries of traditional...

The Questions That Come After an Unexpected Workplace Injury

An ordinary workday can change in a matter of seconds. A misplaced tool, an...

The Changing Landscape of Real Estate: Housing Trends, Growth, and Opportunities

The real estate market has been undergoing significant changes over the past few years, influenced by a multitude of complex factors, encompassing economic circumstances,...

Free Crypto Trading Signals: How to Judge a Prediction Before You Trust It

Learn how to assess free crypto trading signals, check the original claim, compare outcomes fairly, and spot gaps in a published record.

The Building Blocks of Academic Success: Learning, Play, and Physical Activity

Academic success is a multifaceted concept that goes far beyond the boundaries of traditional...

What Will Happen to Your Home After a Divorce?

Divorce can affect nearly every part of a person’s life, including where they live...

What Will Happen to Your Home After a Divorce?

Divorce can affect nearly every part of a person’s life, including where they live...

Is Your CRM a System of Record or a System of Meaning?

CRMs store fields, stages and amounts. But AI agents need more than raw data. Here's why meaning must become queryable, consistent and built into the system.

How AI Is Reshaping the Future of Global Trade

The global economy spent 2025 absorbing tariff shocks, rerouting supply chains and navigating a...

How Cybersecurity Is Becoming Central to Building Trust in India’s Fintech Sector

As digital payments become routine for millions, the industry's credibility rests less on speed and more on how well it protects the people using it.