India's Budget 2025-26 cOVEAGE
Presented by:
spot_img

Walmart faces major India test over Flipkart’s legal tiff with Ratan Tata backed startup

Date:

Trending

An Indian startup‘s legal challenge against Walmart-owned Flipkart claiming losses caused by sharp discounting of its products is winning support from other online sellers, in what is shaping as a key test of how the giant retailer operates in the country.

- Advertisement -

The legal tussle between GOQii, a seller of smartwatch-type health devices, and Flipkart, comes just months after India imposed stricter rules for foreign investment in e-commerce that were aimed at deterring such sharp discounts.

GOQii sued Flipkart last month in a Mumbai court, alleging its devices were discounted by around 70% to the retail price, much more than the two sides had agreed to, legal documents related to the case showed.

- Advertisement -

The case will next be heard on Friday. Flipkart has denied any wrongdoing, saying it was not responsible for any discounts which are only determined by third-party companies which sell on the e-commerce website.

The legal spat has brought to the fore concerns long raised by small traders and a right-wing group close to Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s ruling party.

They say companies such as Flipkart and Amazon deeply discount some products by burning billions of dollars to lure customers onto their sites in the expectation that they will also buy other goods.

“It will set a precedent if the final decision goes against Flipkart for predatory pricing,” said Salman Waris, a partner at TechLegis Advocates & Solicitors “Small traders’ associations and other startups may take other marketplaces adopting deep discounting strategy to court.”

The GOQii case could snowball. The All India Online Vendors Association told Reuters in a statement it plans to file a plea to join GOQii’s case against Flipkart on behalf of 3,500 online sellers it represents.

Flipkart said in a statement it takes legal compliance seriously and was compliant with Indian law. “We are engaged with the supplier to come to a swift resolution,” it said.

With a 19% market share, GOQii was the second-biggest player in India’s so-called wearables market last year, data from industry tracker IDC in December showed. The market is dominated by China’s Xiaomi, with Samsung a small player.

GOQii vs Flipkart

GOQii’s dispute with Flipkart centres around two of its wearables devices that allow users to track exercise measurements, such as the number of steps walked, or heart rates.

GOQii’s Chief Executive Vishal Gondal told Reuters the firm signed an agreement in September with a Flipkart unit, allowing it to sell the two GOQii devices at a price not below Rs 1,999 and Rs 1,499, after discounts.

But GOQii last month found Flipkart’s website showed the devices on sale for Rs 999 and Rs 699. The company wrote to Flipkart, saying it was giving “unauthorized” discounts and resorting to “predatory pricing”, violating the agreement, its legal notice showed.

Flipkart was just a business-to-business wholesale venture which sells good to re-sellers, its law firm, Shardul Amarchand Mangaldas, said in its response that was seen by Reuters.

That’s central to how Flipkart operates – as India prohibits foreign e-commerce firms from stocking and selling their own inventory on its websites, their wholesale units purchase goods in bulk and sell them to re-sellers. Those re-sellers use Flipkart’s own website to sell some of those goods to customers.

Flipkart does not control or influence prices which were determined by such re-sellers, the law firm said, adding that it reserves “the right to institute actions for defamation, both civil and criminal”.

GOQii’s Gondal, however, said he was in possession of WhatsApp messages and e-mails from Flipkart’s employees that show the company was aware and involved in discounting products on its website. He declined to share those with Reuters, citing the ongoing court case.

Gondal said about 500,000 device orders were cancelled after GOQii’s other customers accused the startup of cheating them when they saw cheaper prices on Flipkart. The company was also assessing monetary damages it plans to seek from court.

“It’s a matter of survival. It’s not easy to take on a multi-billion-dollar company,” Gondal said.

In interim relief, the court has ordered the sellers, who are also party to the case, to remove the wearable devices from the Flipkart platform.

Walmart’s struggles

India’s new foreign investment rules introduced in February were troubling for Flipkart and Amazon as they barred companies from selling products via firms in which they have an equity interest and stopped them from pushing their sellers to sell exclusively on their websites.

The policy was aimed at deterring deep discounts and helping small traders, but it shocked Walmart as it had just months ago closed its biggest deal by investing $16 billion in Flipkart.

Swadeshi Jagran Manch (SJM), the economic wing of the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh, the ideological parent of Modi’s ruling party, said on Tuesday the government must investigate online discounts.

“We are standing behind any small trader, businesses who suffer online,” said Ashwani Mahajan, SJM’s co-convenor, adding it would discuss GOQii’s legal case against Flipkart with government officials.

THE SNAPSHOTS

Sign up to get quick snaps of everyday happening, directly in your inbox.

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

- Advertisement -

Support our independent journalism PayPal (Outside India) For PayU (For Indian Readers).

Krishna Mali
Krishna Mali
Founder & Group Editor of TechGraph.

More Latest Stories

More Articles

Preparing Your Staff To Host A Successful Business Event In Another City

A business event, a convention, and exhibition, a trade show - all of these alternatives, similar as they are, can be truly significant for...

TradeFT Review: Comprehensive Platform Overview 2025

The financial markets are abuzz with some pretty exciting developments as 2025 gets underway, particularly in the world of cryptocurrencies. Not long ago, Bitcoin broke through the $100,000 barrier prelude to a new beginning of growth and possibility for investors. In this exciting environment,...

Income Tax Slabs Revised in Budget 2025-26: Experts Applaud Relief for Salaried Class, VDA Taxation Still a Concern

With income tax exemption raised to ₹12.75 lakh and revisions in tax slabs, the...

Union Budget 2025-26: MSME Leaders Back Investment Limit Hike, Call E-Shram Expansion Crucial

The MSME sector has responded positively to the Union Budget 2025-26, with experts highlighting...

Union Budget 2025-26 Reactions: Education Sector Applauds AI, Skilling Initiatives but Flags Funding Gaps

India’s education sector leaders have responded to the Union Budget 2025-26 with optimism and...

Union Budget 2025: India’s AI Budget Allocation Stirs Mixed Reactions

India’s Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman's announcement of a ₹500 crore fund for a Centre...

Union Budget 2025: Medical Education Seats Increased by 130% in 10 Years; 10,000 More to Be Added

Education sector Budget LIVE: Presenting the Union Budget 2025-26, Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman announced...

Union Budget 2025: Kisan Credit Card Loan Limit Increased to ₹5 Lakh Under Modified Interest Subvention Scheme

Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman, in her Union Budget 2025-26 speech, announced an increase in...

From GCC & AI to DeepTech Investments: How Tech Experts React to the Union Budget 2025

Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman’s Union Budget 2025-26 has drawn mixed reactions from technology industry leaders, particularly on the government’s push for deep tech and...

Union Budget 2025: IIT Student Strength Doubles, ₹500 Crore AI Education Center Announced

Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman, while presenting the Union Budget 2025-26 in Parliament today, outlined...

Union Budget 2025 LIVE: FM Sitharaman Announces Reforms in Finance Sector; Increases FDI Limit to 100%

Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman, while presenting the Union Budget for 2025-26 in Parliament today,...

Budget 2025 Expectations: Education Sector Call for Investment in Education Infrastructure and Support for Skill Training

With the Union Budget 2025 on the horizon, the education and skill development sector...

AI in Skill Development: What Budget 2025 Should Do to Close the Workforce Skills Gap

India, with its vast pool of young talent, faces a significant challenge: a widening...

Union Budget 2025 Expectations: Hospitality Sector Urges Budget Support for Tourism Growth and Workforce Development

With the Union Budget 2025 on the horizon, hospitality sector leaders are calling for stronger government support to fuel tourism growth. Industry voices highlight...

Cash out Tether USDT to Renminbi in Guangzhou

If you need to quickly and safely Cash out Tether USDT to Renminbi in Guangzhou, then it is best to use the services of electronic exchangers. They provide more convenient, more profitable and safer ways of exchange than alternative methods such as transfers through...

Union Budget 2025 Expectations: Insurance Sector Eyes Tax Incentives, Sops to Expand Health Insurance Reach

As Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman prepares to present the Union Budget 2025 on February...

Union Budget 2025: Farming, Agriculture Sector Pushes for Greater Subsidies, Policy Support

With Union Budget 2025 just days away, the agriculture sector is vouching for a...

Gaming Industry Eyes Budget 2025 for Relief on GST and Boosted AVGC Support

With the Union Budget just days away, the gaming sector is growing hopeful that...

Budget 2025: Tax Reforms, Infrastructure Financing, and NBFC Support Top Budget Wishlist

As Budget 2025 approaches, experts from the NBFC, finance, and business sectors are voicing...

Adoption of Low Code Platforms by MSMEs for Operational Efficiency of Their Supply Chains

Micro, small, and medium enterprises are the backbone of the world and account for...

Krikya Bangladesh Casino App Review

The Krikya app delivers a seamless and engaging mobile gambling experience for users of...

Union Budget 2025 Expectations: Housing, Real Estate Sector Call for Middle-Class Relief and Affordable Housing Revival

With just days to go before the Union Budget 2025, leaders from the real...

Luck vs. Strategy: Spinstralia’s Guide to Smarter Gaming for Australians

Online betting has always been a thrilling activity for Australians, a pastime that blends...

EV Sector Call for 5% GST, ITC Reforms, and Enhanced PLI in Budget 2025

As the date for the Union Budget 2025 draws near, the electric vehicle (EV)...

Budget 2025 Expectations: Education Sector Call for Investment in Education Infrastructure and Support for Skill Training

With the Union Budget 2025 on the horizon, the education and skill development sector...

Budget 2025: Pre-Owned Car Market Requests Financing Reforms, Auto Industry Looks for GST Clarity

With the Union Budget just days away, the auto sector is hoping for game-changing...

Budget 2025 Expectations: Semiconductor Industry Looks for Support to Boost Domestic Manufacturing, Incentives, and Innovation Investment

As India's Union Budget 2025 approaches, the semiconductor manufacturing sector is seeking measures to...

BUDGET 2025: Sustainability Sector Hopes for Strong Budget Support to Drive Clean Energy and Circular Economy

As the Union Budget 2025 draws near, expectations are building in the sustainable and...

Solar, Renewable Sector Expects Tax Breaks, Subsidies for BESS & Solar Financing Reform From Budget 2025

As Union Budget 2025 approaches, renewable energy leaders are urging Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman...

AI in Skill Development: What Budget 2025 Should Do to Close the Workforce Skills Gap

India, with its vast pool of young talent, faces a significant challenge: a widening...

Luck vs. Strategy: Spinstralia’s Guide to Smarter Gaming for Australians

Online betting has always been a thrilling activity for Australians, a pastime that blends...

REVIEW: PokieSurf Casino Mobile Gaming Experience

If you’re chasing the thrill of online casino no deposit bonus free spins Australia,...

EV Sector Call for 5% GST, ITC Reforms, and Enhanced PLI in Budget 2025

As the date for the Union Budget 2025 draws near, the electric vehicle (EV)...