HomeInsideUK Lawyer: Locking people up to stop coronavirus spread can prompt legal fights

UK Lawyer: Locking people up to stop coronavirus spread can prompt legal fights

Reader's Pick

The UK health secretary on Monday morning authorized an unprecedented policy for stopping possible carriers of the coronavirus: Lock them up. It was the first time in modern British history that such a move has been made in response to an epidemic — and it could prompt legal challenges.

The law, introduced under emergency measures, gives the government the power to detain any individuals who may be infected with the virus for at least 14 days, and to force them to give swabs. The decision came after a person in quarantine threatened to leave.

In the US, the government has resorted to similar laws. It’s the first time such a policy has been used in America since the 1960s, when a quarantine order was issued to stop the spread of smallpox, and more than a century since it was used on such a scale.

The measures stop well short of the response to the outbreak in China, where the authorities have locked down cities and regions with tens of millions of residents. Still, the moves are unprecedented in recent years for western democracies as governments try to balance the need to protect public health against a desire to uphold individual rights.

- Advertisement -

‘Unusual step’

“The unusual step of government making regulations which came into force immediately, before parliamentary scrutiny of them, demonstrates the evolving nature of the threat from the virus and the challenges faced,” said Mark Mills, a London lawyer at Kingsley Napley, referring to the UK measures. “We might yet see the courts drawn in.”

Britain has detained more than 200 people since the virus emerged, according to a person with knowledge of the situation. In the UK, nine people have tested positive for the virus, which has infected tens of thousands of people in China — far more than the severe acute respiratory syndrome, or SARS, epidemic of 2003.

The last time the US government implemented such a wide-ranging quarantine using a federal order was in 1892 to prevent the spread of cholera from ships docking in New York, according to Howard Markel, a professor at the University of Michigan Center for the History of Medicine.

- Advertisement -

As in the UK, the new US measures were implemented after one person tried to leave a quarantine site.

Countries generally rely on people voluntarily submitting to quarantine measures for public safety. While the UK didn’t impose national restrictions over SARS, the epidemic did lead to an overhaul of laws around public safety and infectious diseases, many of which dated to Victorian times. Revisions in 2008 sought to take into account modern risks of radiation and chemical contamination.

‘Extremely draconian’

While there could be challenges to quarantine measures, lawyers don’t think they would be successful, except in unusual personal circumstances. A spokeswoman for the UK Department of Health and Social Care declined to comment beyond Health Secretary Matt Hancock’s statement that said the regulations had been put in place to reduce the risk of further transmission.

“These are provisions that go way beyond what we would normally accept in our society. They’re extremely draconian and invasive,” said Joseph O’Brien, a UK trial lawyer at St John’s Buildings Barristers’ Chambers. “But when the aim is the prevention of infections that could have lasting consequences, I think the courts would accept such measures as necessary.”

close

Stay on top of Budget 2023 with our newsletter

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

close

Stay on top of Budget 2023 with our newsletter

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

- Advertisement -

Read latest Business News and Startup news on TechGraph. Watch live and latest news on TechGraph TV. Follow us on Facebook or follow us on Twitter and Instagram. Listen audio news from TechGraph Briefings on Spotify, Google Podcast, Amazon Music & on Apple Podcast.
 

Krishna Mali
Krishna Mali
Founder & Editor of TechGraph.

Latest News

Promoted Links

Related Stories

Japan approves 26 trillion yen as economic stimulus package to combat overseas risks

Japan's cabinet approved an economic stimulus package worth 26 trillion yen ($2...

1Win App: Review India Apk for Android and iOS

The company 1Win has been successfully operating in the markets of many countri...

Sino-US trade war offers Europe’s chance to bank more Chinese reserves: Analysis

Should European countries want the euro to replace the dollar as the world's do...

Employees union seeks FIR against Jet Airways boss Naresh Goyal, Vinay Dube and on SBI Chairman

The employee union of Jet Airways, which is facing its worst crisis, Friday sou...

Samsung Electronics asks its shareholders to use electronic voting for upcoming AGM

Technology giant Samsung Electronics has adopted electronic voting for the firs...

Rahul Gandhi hits on RCEP says, ‘Make in India’ has become ‘Buy from China’

Asserting that "Make in India" has become "Buy from China," Congress leader Rah...

NASA astronauts to carry first ever all-female spacewalk on 29 March

Two NASA astronauts are scheduled to carry out the first ever all-female spacew...
00:05:54

Union Budget 2023: Five Major Changes to the Personal Income Tax Regime

In a major announcement on income tax changes, the government has revealed five...
00:02:04

Union Budget 2023: Infrastructure Investment with Steep Capital Outlay

The Finance Minister, Nirmala Sitharaman, has announced the Union Budget 2023 w...
00:09:17

What Jammu & Kashmir, Ladakh, Northeast & Agritech got from Budget 2023?

Addressing the parliament on the ongoing union budget session, Finance Minister...