Jury Finds Apple violated three patents of Qualcomm

Date:

Trending

Mobile phone chip supplier Qualcomm Inc on Friday won a legal victory against iPhone maker Apple Inc, with a jury in federal court in San Diego finding that Apple owes Qualcomm about $31 million for infringing three of its patents.

Qualcomm last year sued Apple alleging it had violated patents related to helping mobile phones get better battery life. During an eight-day trial, Qualcomm asked the jury to award it unpaid patent royalties of up to $1.41 per iPhone that violated the patents.

The $31 million penalty is small change for Apple, the second most valuable U.S. company after Microsoft Corp, with a market value of $866 billion and annual revenue totalling hundreds of billions of dollars. But the setting of a per-phone royalty rate for Qualcomm’s technology gives the chip supplier a fresh line of attack in its two-year old legal battle with Apple.

The biggest case, filed by Apple in early 2017, begins in April. Apple has sought to dismantle what it calls Qualcomm’s illegal business model of both licensing patents and selling chips to phone makers. Qualcomm has accused Apple of using its technology without paying.

“The technologies invented by Qualcomm and others are what made it possible for Apple to enter the market and become so successful so quickly,” Don Rosenberg, Qualcomm’s general counsel, said in a statement. “We are gratified that courts all over the world are rejecting Apple’s strategy of refusing to pay for the use of our IP.”

In a statement, Apple said it was disappointed with the outcome.

“Qualcomm’s ongoing campaign of patent infringement claims is nothing more than an attempt to distract from the larger issues they face with investigations into their business practices in U.S. federal court, and around the world,” Apple said. It declined to comment on whether it would appeal.

In other cases against Apple, Qualcomm has won sales bans on iPhones in Germany and China, though the Chinese ban has not been enforced and Apple has taken moves it believes allow it to resume sales in Germany.

Qualcomm also suffered a setback with U.S. trade regulators who found that some iPhones infringed one of the San Diego-based company’s patents but declined to bar their importation into the United States, citing the damage such a move would inflict on rival Intel Corp.

The verdict on Friday could come into play in the trial in April because it puts a per-phone dollar figure on some of Qualcomm’s intellectual property. Qualcomm’s patent licensing model relies on charging phone makers a cut of the selling price of the phone, a practice Apple has alleged is unfair and illegal.

During an earlier trial between Qualcomm and the U.S. Federal Trade Commission, Apple executives outlined their company’s extensive negotiations to reduce those license fees to $7.50 per phone for Qualcomm’s patents.

The San Diego jury valued just three of Qualcomm’s patents in the company’s portfolio at $1.41, a figure that the chip supplier believes bolsters its contention that its licensing practices are fair.

“The three patents found to be infringed in this case represent just a small fraction of Qualcomm’s valuable portfolio of tens of thousands of patents,” Rosenberg said in a statement.

Gaston Kroub, a patent lawyer in New York not involved in the case, said the verdict was clearly a win for Qualcomm. But it does not say much about the value of Qualcomm’s entire patent portfolio and was unlikely to spark settlements discussions, he said.

“Apple is very skilled at handling appeals and taking a longer-term view. This isn’t something that will bring Apple to the table with any sense of urgency,” Kroub said.

(Reporting by Stephen Nellis in San Francisco and Jan Wolfe in Washington; Editing by Richard Chang)

THE SNAPSHOTS, IN YOUR INBOX

Get quick snaps of everyday happening, directly in your inbox.

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

Support our independent journalism PayPal (Outside India) For PayU (For Indian Readers).

Krishna Mali
Krishna Mali
Founder & Group Editor of TechGraph.

More Latest Stories

More Articles

Godrej Capital’s Gen AI Plan: CTO Jyothirlatha B on SAKSHAM AI and the Future of Financial Services

Speaking to TechGraph, Godrej Capital CTO Jyothirlatha B shared how the company is harnessing GenAI to accelerate credit assessments and enhance customer service. She...

Preparing for a Data-Driven Future: How the GRE Assesses Academic and Analytical Readiness

As sectors such as artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning continue to grow and develop, the demand for professionals with analytical and critical thinking skills is at an all-time high with employers. The ability to analyze data, solve complex problems, and take up interdisciplinary...

Exploring the broad appeal of football: from fashion to video games

Football, often called the world's game, goes far beyond the pitch. Its influence extends...

Neon54 Casino Review: A Vibrant Gaming Experience

When it comes to striking the perfect balance between entertainment and innovation, Neon54 Casino...

How Generative AI is Shaping Voicebot Capabilities

The advent of Generative AI is here to revolutionize the technological landscape and reimagine...
00:08:12

Congress-Led Opposition Calls for Vice President Dhankhar Removal

India Congress lead opposition coalition also known as the INDIA bloc, has formally submitted...

Decentralizing Cardiac Care: Sunfox Technologies’ Rajat Jain on the Spandan ECG Impact

During an interview with the TechGraph editorial team, Sunfox Technologies' Founder and CEO, Rajat...

Boson Whitewater, Citadines OMR Chennai to Launch First-of-its-Kind Wastewater Recycling System

Boson Whitewater, a water utility company that converts STP-treated water into high-quality potable water,...

BProTrade: Global Expansion Explained

December 2024 marks a pivotal time in the world of online trading. With Bitcoin crossing the $100,000 mark and altcoins like Dogecoin and Toncoin...

Jungle Camps India Limited Sets IPO Price Band at ₹68-₹72 per Share

Jungle Camps India Limited (JCIL), an India-based ecological hospitality service provider on Thursday announced...

Atmosphere The Store Makers draws INR 5 Cr in seed round

Mumbai based Atmosphere – The Store Makers on Thursday raised INR 5 crore in...

Voice-Based AI and SLMs: Gnani Ai CEO Ganesh Gopalan On India’s Voice AI Boom

During an interview with TechGraph, Ganesh Gopalan, Co-founder of Gnani.ai, discussed how voice-based AI,...

Top Trends in Web3 Platforms for Forward-Thinking Entrepreneurs

The digital landscape is evolving rapidly, and Web3 platforms are leading this transformation. For...
00:00:20

Benjamin Netanyahu: Thank You President Donald Trump for Calling Hamas to Release Hostages

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu on Tuesday expressed his gratitude to U.S. President-Elect Donald Trump for his recent call for Hamas to release hostages. https://open.spotify.com/episode/6xpUQdGpNQUkwHNPXP7WgP?si=ro44gKgxR1yn6qBbj6iXpw "I...

Titan Intech Ltd To Secure Rs 200 Cr via NCDs

Titan Intech Limited, a BSE-listed company specializing in Embedded Manufacturing Services (EMS) for OEM/ODM solutions and advanced embedded systems, has announced plans to secure Rs 200 crore through Non-Convertible Debentures (NCDs). The funds will be utilized to accelerate the company's strategic initiatives in high-growth sectors,...

Ensuring Fair Play: AIGF CEO Roland Landers on Promoting Skill-Based Gaming in India

During an interview with TechGraph, Roland Landers, CEO of the All India Gaming Federation...

The Evolution of Gaming: From Traditional to Immersive Online Experiences

Gaming has undergone a remarkable transformation over the decades, evolving from basic, tactile forms...

How AI is Transforming Traditional Business Roles

Artificial Intelligence has already had a significant impact on businesses and has made data-driven...

The Impact of Real-Time Market Data Solutions on Informed Trading Decisions

The world of finance isn’t stagnant; it is dynamic and ever-evolving. Every second, a...

AI and Workplace Equality for Women in the Digital Era

As society heads toward an age dominated by technology, a key question remains: will...

OPPO, Microsoft Teams up To Bring Advanced AI Productivity To ColorOS 15

OPPO has strengthened its partnership with Microsoft to deliver advanced AI productivity features to...

The Hidden World of Mega888 APK: What Casual Players Are Missing Out On

Mega888 APK is well-known among online casino enthusiasts for its thrilling games and easy-to-navigate...

The Importance of Zero-Trust Security Models in Safeguarding Data

In an age where cyberattacks grow more sophisticated by the day, traditional security models...

Crypto Market Crosses $3.08 Trn, Bitcoin Hits $91,616, Litecoin Drops Below $90

The cryptocurrency market surged to a total valuation of $3.08 trillion on Monday, with...

Voice-Based AI and SLMs: Gnani Ai CEO Ganesh Gopalan On India’s Voice AI Boom

During an interview with TechGraph, Ganesh Gopalan, Co-founder of Gnani.ai, discussed how voice-based AI,...

The Role of Health Plans with Preventive Care in Reducing Financial Risk

In an era where healthcare costs are spiraling and chronic conditions are on the...

What’s next for Battery Recycling: Innovations on the Horizon

India is accelerating its shift toward electrification and renewable energy, bringing battery recycling into...

Unexpected Tips To Help Maintain Your Vehicle’s Condition

When it comes to prolonging the life of your vehicle, the condition of your...

Discover the Features of Melbet’s Mobile App for Indian Bettors

The Melbet mobile application has been designed to cater to the growing community of...

Top Trends in Web3 Platforms for Forward-Thinking Entrepreneurs

The digital landscape is evolving rapidly, and Web3 platforms are leading this transformation. For...

The Importance of Zero-Trust Security Models in Safeguarding Data

In an age where cyberattacks grow more sophisticated by the day, traditional security models...

Indusface Launches CyberShiksha program to Educate Students on Cybersecurity

Indusface, a leading application security provider for SaaS solutions, has launched CyberShiksha, a national...

Crypto Market Crosses $3.08 Trn, Bitcoin Hits $91,616, Litecoin Drops Below $90

The cryptocurrency market surged to a total valuation of $3.08 trillion on Monday, with...