Sino-US trade war offers Europe’s chance to bank more Chinese reserves: Analysis

Date:

Trending

Should European countries want the euro to replace the dollar as the world’s dominant reserve currency, the Sino-US trade war may offer a window of opportunity.

- Advertisement -

The souring of ties between the world’s two largest economies will indicate the extent to which China can switch some of its giant reserve holdings to another hard currency and also point to the limitations the euro zone faces in providing a viable alternative.

In the post-World War Two era, no asset has ever fully matched US government bonds for size, liquidity and credit quality. It is the closest any global security has come to being perceived as a cash-like, risk-free asset with over $16 trillion worth of paper in circulation.

- Advertisement -

Yet, a year into a bitter tariff war, there are some signs of Beijing’s discomfort at being both the United States‘ biggest trade adversary and one of its biggest creditors.

Recent data showed China sold more US Treasuries in March than it has in any month over the past 2-1/2 years. If that proves to be more than a one-month quirk, speculation will rise about where it is diverting those reserves, and the euro zone – the world’s biggest trading bloc – tops the list of likely spots.

On size alone, euro zone government bonds appear to provide a credible landing pad: outstanding securities are almost two-thirds of the overall Treasury market.

There are signs already of greater Chinese interest in Europe — bankers attribute record Asian demand for recent Spanish, French and Belgian debt sales to Beijing.

And China has stepped up buying debt from Europe’s quasi-sovereign entities, bankers told Reuters, in particular the European Stability Mechanism (ESM) a euro zone-guaranteed AAA/A1-rated bailout fund.

Asian investors snapped up 33% of the ESM’s recent 2 billion-euro 10-year bond, data from International Financing Review shows. Asian takeup for ESM’s euro issues last year was 4%-5%.

But for Chinese reserve managers to shift hundreds of billions of dollars from Treasuries to Europe‘s single currency, the euro bloc needs to address key shortcomings.

“I find it hard to square the circle how such a huge Treasury holding can be diversified away, given the landscape we are in,” said Salman Ahmed, chief investment strategist at Lombard Odier Investment Managers.

“In the euro zone there is not a big risk-free market…Twenty years down the line it may be different.”

For Ahmed, the main issue is that credit risk in the bloc is not uniform. The 19 members each run their own fiscal policies, budget rules are too loosely policed to ensure adherence, and euro exit remains a theoretical possibility.

So wealthier members such as Germany remain net savers that run balanced budgets or even surpluses, while others, mostly in southern Europe, are dogged by high debt.

The resulting mix of credit and political risks make it harder to see the aggregate euro zone bond market as a true mirror of the US Treasury universe.

Ross Hutchison, a fund manager at Aberdeen Standard Investments, says it boils down to the fact the United States “has a federal nature that the euro area hasn’t got yet”.

Additionally, distortions stemming from years of bond buying stimulus by the European Central Bank mean available euro government bonds are far fewer than may appear.

While euro government debt outstanding is around $9.5 trillion, the ECB is estimated to hold roughly a quarter.

And the kind of “safe” securities that reserve managers seek are even scarcer — AAA-rated debt from Germany, the Netherlands and Luxembourg totals around $2.5 trillion, less if ECB holdings are discounted. Debt from slightly lower-rated France, Belgium and Austria would add another $3 trillion.

Italy on the other hand has the bloc’s biggest government bond market, worth $2.3 trillion. But its poor debt-to-GDP ratio, sluggish economy and populist policies make its bonds riskier and its credit rating is a notch or two above junk.

So in times of stress, investors clamour for German bonds, while in Italy, yields spike, threatening to undermine local banks that hold these securities.

Italian 10-year yields are at 2.5%, versus Germany’s minus 0.22%.

Such risks have chipped away at the euro’s fortunes as a reserve currency — International Monetary Fund data shows it comprises 20% of global central bank holdings, from 26% in 2009.

The decline is linked to the 2011 Greek debt crisis that then ravaged Spain, Italy, Portugal and Ireland, highlighting risks of default by a member state and redenomination of euro debt into a new currency.

COMMON BOND?

European officials are keen to counter the dollar’s hegemony, and at a conference last month they debated ways to win the euro a “stronger international role”.

But they made no mention of the one measure that could resolve the issue at a stroke — joint debt issuance via common euro zone bonds. Such securities would pool the bloc’s risks, and offer safer securities than those from most individual nations.

Olli Rehn, Bank of Finland governor and an ECB governing council member, said last week a safe asset would help enhance the euro’s international role, offering hope the issue will be on the agenda of the new European Commission later this year.

A common bond “would be more significant than the creation of another TLTRO in boosting demand for euros globally and reserve managers would be part of that story,” said David Owen, chief European economist at Jefferies.

He was referring to the ECB’s cheap multi-year loans.

“Maybe there will be more focus on pushing forward this agenda and taking advantage of the U.S and China having this trade spat,” Owen added.

Others, however, note that wealthier states oppose any common bond programme, fearing they will end up footing the bill. Also, across Europe populist and anti-establishment movements are on the rise, with the agenda of slowing integration and returning power to national capitals.

Such groups grabbed a greater share of the vote in EU parliamentary elections last month, albeit less than expected.

“If anything, the trend is towards decentralisation of power,” Ahmed said.

THE SNAPSHOTS

Sign up to get quick snaps of everyday happening, directly in your inbox.

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

- Advertisement -

Support our independent journalism PayPal (Outside India) For PayU (For Indian Readers).

Krishna Mali
Krishna Mali
Founder & Group Editor of TechGraph.

More Latest Stories

More Articles

Football: Real Madrid beat CF Pachuca 3-1 in Group H clash

Jude Bellingham and Arda Guler scored late in the first half to help 10-man Real Madrid secure a 3-1 victory over CF Pachuca in...

IAEA expresses ‘serious concern’ after US strikes on Iran

In response to U.S. airstrikes on Iranian nuclear facilities, the head of the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) has called an emergency meeting in Vienna. IAEA Director General Rafael Grossi expressed serious concern over the likely damage inflicted on Iran’s underground Fordow uranium enrichment plant,...

Iran pledges decisive action after US airstrikes on nuclear sites

An emergency meeting of the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) was convened in Vienna...

GW Casino Review & FAQ: Real Talk for Aussie Punters

With the avalanche of cookie-cutter online casinos hitting Aussie screens, most punters have seen...

Pichai Family Foundation to Sell 4,000 Alphabet Shares Worth $708K

The Pichai Family Foundation filed a notice with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission...

Sundar Pichai Sales Alphabet Stock Worth $5.6 Million

Alphabet Inc. (NASDAQ: GOOGL) CEO Sundar Pichai filed a notice with the U.S. Securities...

Iran May Exit Nuclear Treaty Under New Bill

Iranian parliamentarians are drafting a bill that could pave the way for the country...

NSE India, Cyprus Stock Exchange Sign MoU for Dual Listings, Financial Innovation

India’s National Stock Exchange (NSE) and the Cyprus Stock Exchange signed a memorandum of...

Finding the Right Custom Home Builder in Bay City: Reviews & Recommendations

Building a new home is one of life’s most exciting milestones—but it also comes with big decisions. One of the most crucial is choosing...

Mark Zuckerberg Sells $21 Mn in Meta Shares, Files to Offload $9 Mn More

Meta Platforms (NASDAQ: META) CEO Mark Zuckerberg has filed to sell another $9.7 million...

Khair and Tunu Wood Seized in Major Operation by Jammu Forest Department

Acting on specific intelligence, the Forest Department team in Tehsil Bhalwal intercepted and seized...

London-Ahmedabad Plane Crash: Air India to Operate Relief Flights

Air India is operating two relief flights for the next of kin of passengers...

Congo: Over 29 dead as floods, landslides hit Kinshasa

At least 29 people died in Kinshasa after heavy rains over the weekend triggered...

Sharp Bettors vs Recreational Bettors: What Sets Them Apart?

In the U.S. alone, over $120 billion was legally wagered on sports in 2023, and analysts estimate that offshore and crypto sportsbooks handled an...

Security Forces Deploy Facial Recognition Tech on Pahalgam Route to Secure Shri Amarnath Yatra

Jammu and Kashmir: In a first-of-its-kind move, security forces have installed advanced facial recognition technology along the Pahalgam route ahead of the annual Shri Amarnath Ji Yatra. The cutting-edge system is designed to swiftly identify blacklisted individuals, including potential terror suspects, among the influx...

Air India Plane Crash: Over 60 victims identified via DNA

Days after Air India’s Ahmedabad-to-London flight crashed with 242 passengers and crew on board,...

What You Need to Consider When Starting an HVAC Company

Entering the HVAC industry is a significant business decision that comes with both challenges...

ISRO Schedules June 19 for Ax-4 Mission Launch Carrying Indian Astronaut to ISS

The Indian Space Research Organisation (ISRO) on Saturday announced that the Ax-4 mission to...

India Distances Itself from SCO Stance on Israel’s Attack On Iran, Calls for Dialogue

India has opted out of a recent Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO) statement that strongly...

Los Angeles Protests: President Trump Deploys 700 Marines, 200 to Secure Federal Building

As nationwide protests against the Trump administration are expected to unfold across the U.S....

Manipur: Security Forces Seize 328 Guns, 9,300 Rounds in Joint Raids

In a major crackdown, security forces recovered a large cache of arms and ammunition...

Meta’s Chief Legal Officer Offloads $363,219 in Shares Under Pre-Arranged Plan

Meta Platforms Inc.’s Chief Legal Officer Jennifer Newstead sold 519 shares of the company’s...

Alphabet Shareholders Reject All 13 Proposals, Re-elect Entire Board

Alphabet Inc. (NASDAQ: GOOGL) shareholders rejected all 13 investor proposals at the company’s annual...

Sri Lanka To Raise Electricity Tariff By 15 Percent

Sri Lanka will increase electricity tariffs by 15% starting June 12, the Public Utilities...

London-Ahmedabad Plane Crash: Air India to Operate Relief Flights

Air India is operating two relief flights for the next of kin of passengers...

Cybersecurity Theater: Why Companies Still Fall for the Illusion of Control

The world now experiences daily security breaches on evening news while ransomware groups operate...

India’s Tier 2 & 3 Cities: The New Battleground for Smart Delivery

India’s economic narrative is undergoing a profound transformation, shifting its gaze from the bustling...

ICG Transfers Distressed MV Wan Hai 503 to Tug Offshore Warrior in Kochi

In a key maritime operation, the Indian Coast Guard (ICG) successfully transferred the tow...

Civil Aviation Ministry: High-Level Panel to Probe Air India Flight Crash

The Ministry of Civil Aviation has constituted a high-level multi-disciplinary committee to investigate the...

Congo: Over 29 dead as floods, landslides hit Kinshasa

At least 29 people died in Kinshasa after heavy rains over the weekend triggered...

Alphabet Shareholders Reject All 13 Proposals, Re-elect Entire Board

Alphabet Inc. (NASDAQ: GOOGL) shareholders rejected all 13 investor proposals at the company’s annual...

BGC Director Arthur Mbanefo Sells Shares Worth Over $295k Amid Company Buyback

Arthur U. Mbanefo, a board member at BGC Group Inc., sold a total of...

Sri Lanka To Raise Electricity Tariff By 15 Percent

Sri Lanka will increase electricity tariffs by 15% starting June 12, the Public Utilities...